2586 PROSPECT STREET

$ 1,499,000
2586 PROSPECT STREET, Sarasota
  • Updated On:
  • September 16, 2025
  • Property Size
  • 3,585 ft2
  • Bathrooms
  • 4
  • Bedrooms
  • 4
  • Rooms
  • 12

Description

You won’t find a home this spacious for a better price east of the trail! Located in the city of Sarasota’s overlay district, zoned to allow for 7 night short-term rentals / exceptional income producing opportunities in the heart of town! Discover the perfect blend of contemporary design, thoughtful upgrades, and prime location in Sarasota’s sought-after Arlington Park neighborhood, “East of the Trail.” Designed and constructed by Oliver Caletti in 2020. This exquisite home offers over 3,500 square feet of living space, featuring three bedrooms, four bathrooms, multiple versatile bonus rooms, and plenty of space for a pool! The oversized 900+ square foot primary suite boasts a luxurious bedroom, spa-like bath, and two walk-in closets. Designed for culinary enthusiasts, the chef’s kitchen has been upgraded with GE Café appliances, quartz countertops, an induction cooktop, and a walk-in pantry. High-end finishes throughout the home include custom lighting in every room, Italian porcelain tiles, white oak floors, solid wood cabinetry, plantation shutters, and level 5 drywall coated with EuroLux Fine Paints throughout, enhancing its elegance and durability.

Additional upgrades include a privacy wall, A.O. Smith 80-gallon water heater, Toto toilets and Monte Carlo ceiling fans, ensuring comfort and convenience. The indoor-outdoor living experience is unmatched, with a large screened lanai featuring a Mont Alpi outdoor kitchen, a private walled backyard, and room to add a pool. Additional spaces include a den or optional 4th bedroom with a full bath and a bonus room perfect for an office, wine room, or secondary laundry setup, an upstairs loft. Built with exceptional quality, the home features solid block construction, hurricane impact windows and doors, a whole-house salt-free water softener, and is located in an elevated Zone X non-flood zone location.

Nestled on a corner lot, the property is just steps from the 20-acre Arlington Park, offering swimming pools, tennis courts, a basketball gym, a ½-mile walking trail, and a dog park. It’s also conveniently close to downtown Sarasota, Southside Village, and the area’s pristine beaches. This home is a masterpiece of modern craftsmanship, thoughtful upgrades, and refined finishes in one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods. Don’t miss your chance to call Arlington Park home!

Listing Id: A4630922
Price: $ 1,499,000
Property Size: 3,585 ft2
Property Lot Size: 0 ft2
Rooms: 12
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 4
Architectural Style: Custom
Bathrooms Full: 4
Modification Timestamp: September 8, 2025 at 08:39pm
Building Area Total: 3756
Construction Materials: Block, Stucco
Cooling: Central Air
CoveredSpaces: 2
CumulativeDaysOnMarket: 280
DaysOnMarket: 280
DirectionFaces: North
Directions: Head South on US41. Turn left/East onto Prospect Street. The home is on the right? Or East on Bahia Vista to Euclid Ave; Right on Euclid Ave. to Prospect. Home is on the southwest corner of the street.
Flooring: Engineered Hardwood, Tile
FoundationDetails: Slab
GarageSpaces: 2
Heating: Central, Electric
IDXParticipationYN: 1
InternetAddressDisplayYN: 1
InternetAutomatedValuationDisplayYN: 1
InternetConsumerCommentYN: 1
InternetEntireListingDisplayYN: 1
LaundryFeatures: Laundry Room, Upper Level
LeaseConsideredYN: 1
Levels: Two
List AOR: Port Charlotte
List Agent AOR: Sarasota - Manatee
List Agent Email: laurenholtrealtor@gmail.com
List Agent Full Name: Lauren Holt, PLLC
List Agent MlsId: 281521369
List OfficeKey: caaafdce14e2427189353e5b5faa76f5
ListOfficeMlsId: 274501900
ListOfficeName: COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
ListOfficePhone: 305-851-2820
Listing Terms: Cash, Conventional, Other
Living Area Source: Public Records
Living Area Units: Square Feet
Lot Features: Corner Lot
LotSizeArea: 7226
LotSizeDimensions: 50 x 107
LotSizeSquareFeet: 7226
LotSizeUnits: Square Feet
MLSAreaMajor: 34239 - Sarasota/Pinecraft
MlsStatus: Active
ModificationTimestamp: September 8, 2025 at 08:33pm
OnMarketDate: 2024-12-01
Originating System Name: Stellar MLS
Ownership: Fee Simple
Parcel Number: 2035020001
Property Condition: Completed
Roof: Shingle
Sewer: Public Sewer
State Or Province: FL
Status Change Timestamp: July 1, 2025 at 02:46pm
Stories Total: 2
Street Name: PROSPECT
Street Number: 2586
Street Number Numeric: 2586
Street Suffix: STREET
Tax Annual Amount: 7926
Tax Block: C
Tax Book Number: 5-89
Tax Year: 2023
Utilities: BB/HS Internet Available, Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Underground Utilities, Water Connected
View: Garden
Water Source: Public
Window Features: Shutters
Year Built: 2020
Zoning: RSF4
FeedTypes: IDX
Source System Key: 742095488
Originating System Key: stellar
OriginalEntryTimestamp: December 1, 2024 at 11:31pm
OriginalListPrice: 1950000

Address: 2586 PROSPECT STREET
City:
State/County:
Zip: 34239
Country: United States

Outdoor Details
Garage Attached
Other Features
Balcony
Built-in Features
Built-In Oven
Ceiling Fan(s)
Courtyard
Dishwasher
Dryer
Has a View
Has Cooling System
Has Garage
Has Heating System
Kitchen/Family Room Combo
Open Floorplan
PrimaryBedroom Upstairs
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
Sliding Doors
Solid Surface Counters
Solid Wood Cabinets
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer
Water Softener

There are no results found for this property address.yelp logo

$ 7,685.67
per month
  • Principal and Interest
  • Property Tax
  • HOA fee
$ 5,811.92

Thu 25 Sep
Fri 26 Sep
Sat 27 Sep
Sun 28 Sep
Mon 29 Sep
Tue 30 Sep
Wed 01 Oct
Thu 02 Oct
Fri 03 Oct
Sat 04 Oct
In Person
Video Chat

Contact Me

Schedule a showing?

Similar Listings

5009 JODY AVENUE
Residential
Active
$ 325,000

5009 JODY AVENUE

MLS #
A4657381
Beds:
3
Baths:
2
mls_logoProvided by Stellar MLS
Call
Email
3135 FOUNDERS CLUB DRIVE
Residential
Active
$ 4,799,900

3135 FOUNDERS CLUB DRIVE

Beds:
4
Baths:
4
mls_logoProvided by Stellar MLS
Call
Email
DISCLAIMER TEXT: 2586 PROSPECT STREET | 534757 © 2023 All material presented here is for information purposes only.

Compare Listings

Janet Richmond